HRG Property Management Blog

HRG Admin - Tuesday, October 7, 2025
{{ post.title }}

Allowing pets in your Fort Myers rental can attract more tenants and increase occupancy rates, but it may also lead to property damage and additional maintenance responsibilities. Weighing these pros and cons helps landlords make informed, profitable decisions.

Imagine showing a well-maintained rental property in Fort Myers, FL, to a prospective tenant. When the topic of allowing pets in your rental property comes up, you can practically see their eyes light up. The truth is, pet-friendly rentals can be a game-changer in the competitive housing market. But is it the right move for you as a landlord?

What Are the Benefits of Allowing Pets in Your Rental Property?

Allowing pets can significantly increase your pool of potential renters. Many tenants own pets and are often willing to pay a premium for a home that accommodates their furry friends. Here are some compelling benefits of making your rental pet-friendly:

  • Wider Tenant Base: By allowing pets, you attract more applications, particularly from families with pets
  • Higher Rental Rates: Many landlords charge pet fees, significantly offsetting any potential damages caused by pets
  • Improved Tenant Satisfaction: When tenants are happy with their living conditions, they are more likely to renew their leases
  • Longer Tenancies: Tenants with pets are often looking for stability, which means they may stay longer, reducing turnover costs

What Are the Risks of Allowing Pets?

While the benefits are appealing, there are notable risks to consider. Some of the challenges that come with allowing pets include:

  • Potential Damage: Pets can cause wear and tear on your property
  • Noise Complaints: Barking dogs can lead to noise complaints from neighbors, which can become a landlord's headache
  • Liability Issues: Allowing dogs can pose a risk of bites or other injuries, leading to legal issues
  • Insurance Considerations: Some insurance policies may not cover pet-related incidents, placing additional responsibilities on the landlord

Crafting a Balanced Pet Policy

To mitigate the downsides of allowing pets in your rental property, consider adopting a clear and concise pet policy. This policy should outline the types of pets allowed, any fees associated with them, and the responsibilities of the tenant. Here are some elements to include:

  • Specify which types of pets are allowed (e.g., dogs, cats, birds)
  • Require pet deposits or non-refundable pet fees
  • Set limits on the number of pets allowed
  • Include guidelines on pet behavior and maintenance

Making the Best Choice for Your Property

Ultimately, the decision to allow pets should be based on your unique rental situation and market needs. Consider your target audience: Fort Myers is a family-friendly community, and many local families are likely to own pets. By conducting thorough vetting of tenants and establishing a solid pet policy, you can strike a balance between welcoming pets and protecting your property.

Choose Wisely and Profit

As you navigate the decision of allowing pets in your rental property, keep in mind the potential financial benefits that a pet-friendly policy can provide. With the right management practices in place, you can ensure that your investment in Fort Myers not only meets market demand but thrives.

For quality property management services nationwide, consider partnering with experienced professionals who understand your unique needs, like HomeRiver Group®. We combine national reach with local expertise by acquiring the best local property management firms and backing them with cutting-edge technology and centralized services across acquisition, renovation, leasing, and maintenance

Contact us for more information.